Not very practical...

 Current Forum Visitors Online:
65 visitors
[ MsHoops Womens Basketball Forum ] [ Follow Ups ] [ Post Followup ]
Posted by: BobSienicki on May 05, 2008 at 16:43:02 - IP 68.38.144.31

In Reply to: Redshirts in 08-09? posted by postupJoe on May 04, 2008 at 10:14:56:

Considering HS & college age women are 4x more likely than men to suffer an ACL tear, redshirting women for reasons other than for injuries is simply not practical. After what we just experienced this past season, I am surprised you even brought it up.

About the only way I would ever support redshirting a female athlete is if you get to the end of the season and she has not played during the season. Even then, you have to wonder whether it might be worth the risk of losing that safety net if the player injures herself later in her career. I am aware players can petition for a second redshirt but that is no guarantee - especially after the first one was blown for player development and/or stockpiling players (which was the reason for ride limits to begin with!)

Finally, if a player has made it to the end of the season without playing, the question arises as to whether the player is valuable enough to tie up that ride for another year vs. keeping the player on pace to graduate thereby freeing up the ride for a better player ASAP.

While your question is valid for men's sports, the greater risks of injuries to female athletes makes it impractical for women's sports.

JMHOAU

BobSienicki
71 Months
Purdue

Follow Ups:
Post a Followup:
If you've posted a follow-up in the past and have cookies active, your name, e-mail, and password should already be entered into the form below!
Name or Nickname:

REQUIRED INFORMATION
 E-Mail Address:

REQUIRED INFORMATION
 Password:

Registered Users Only

Open for everyone
Use this button to submit a
follow-up to post on this page
Open for everyone
Use this button to retrieve
the OGFP Contact Form
Open for everyone
Use this button to report
post on this page as SPAM		 Submit to HOF
Registered Users Only
Use this button to submit
post to OGFP Hall-o-Fame
Edit This Post
Registered Users Only
Use this button to edit
your post on this page		 Email Author
Registered Users Only
Use this button to E-mail
the author of this message		 Admin Polls
Registered Users Only
Use this button to complete
polls about site features

     Welcome, we have a few SIMPLE rules for all forum posts:
  1) ALL POSTS MUST BE PURDUE SPORTS RELATED.
     =No advertising/spam/gambling/casino/pronographic posts, or links
  2) ALL POSTS MUST INCLUDE YOUR REAL NAME.
     =Approved nickname is acceptable
  3) ALL POSTS MUST INCLUDE A VALID E-MAIL ADDRESS.
     =Hotmail/Yahoo accounts are acceptable
  4) NO FOUL LANGUAGE.
     =No insulting/name calling of other posters
  5) DON'T POST ANYTHING ABOUT A PERSON THAT YOU WOULDN'T SAY TO THEIR FACE.
     =Trashing of the coaching staff/players is NOT acceptable
 ***** Any post violating these rules runs the risk of being zapped.

[ MsHoops Womens Basketball Forum ]